Comparison numbers

14 Products researched
7 Research hours
310 Readers
62,479 Customer ratings

Best Cat Toys

Cat Toy Comparison 2023

Trixie 4590
Trixie 4590
Check Price
Catit Super Roller Circuit
Catit Super Roller Circuit
Check Price
Catit Senses 50745
Catit Senses 50745
Check Price
Catit Play 50730A1
Catit Play 50730A1
Check Price
Catit 43154W
Catit 43154W
Check Price
The Natural Pet Company cat toy
The Natural Pet Company cat toy
Check Price
Karlie 46018
Karlie 46018
Check Price
Customer rating (from Amazon)
Deal
Available at
Manufacturer
Material
Number of parts
Age recommendation
Simple cleaning
Fillable with snacks
Strap
Floating
Dental care
Mental stimulation
Light effects
Sound effects
Scratching mat
Advantages
Disadvantages
Amazon Trixie 4590
Rating

1

Trixie 4590
Customer rating
amazon 13,400 ratings
Deal
Available at
amazon
eBay
Manufacturer
Trixie
Material
Plastic, Rubber
Number of parts
1
Age recommendation
Cub, Adult
Simple cleaning
Fillable with snacks
Strap
Floating
Dental care
Mental stimulation
Light effects
Sound effects
Scratching mat
Advantages
  • Easy to clean
  • Can be filled with various snacks
  • Stimulates cats' brains
Disadvantages
  • No light effects
  • Scratching mat is not included
Amazon Catit Super Roller Circuit
Rating

2

Catit Super Roller Circuit
Customer rating
amazon 15,246 ratings
Deal
Available at
amazon
eBay
Manufacturer
Catit
Material
Plastic
Number of parts
8
Age recommendation
Simple cleaning
Fillable with snacks
Strap
Floating
Dental care
Mental stimulation
Light effects
Sound effects
Scratching mat
Advantages
  • Scratching mat for letting off steam
  • Sound effects
  • Stimulates cats' brains
Disadvantages
  • No engaging light effects
Amazon Catit Senses 50745
Rating

3

Catit Senses 50745
Customer rating
amazon 6,030 ratings
Deal
Available at
amazon
eBay
Manufacturer
Catit
Material
Plastic
Number of parts
2
Age recommendation
Cub, Adult
Simple cleaning
Fillable with snacks
Strap
Floating
Dental care
Mental stimulation
Light effects
Sound effects
Scratching mat
Advantages
  • Sound effects
  • Just fill with snacks and let the animals play
  • Easy to clean
  • For curious kittens who want to learn
Disadvantages
  • No engaging light effects
  • Scratching mat is not included
Amazon Catit Play 50730A1
Rating

4

Catit Play 50730A1
Customer rating
amazon 4,933 ratings
Deal
Available at
amazon
eBay
Manufacturer
Catit
Material
Plastic
Number of parts
2
Age recommendation
Cub, Adult
Simple cleaning
Fillable with snacks
Strap
Floating
Dental care
Mental stimulation
Light effects
Sound effects
Scratching mat
Advantages
  • Stimulates cats' brains
  • Easy to clean
  • Sound effects
Disadvantages
  • No light effects
  • No scratching mat
Amazon Catit 43154W
Rating

5

Catit 43154W
Customer rating
amazon 8,843 ratings
Deal
Available at
amazon
eBay
Manufacturer
Catit
Material
Plastic
Number of parts
21
Age recommendation
Cub, Adult
Simple cleaning
Fillable with snacks
Strap
Floating
Dental care
Mental stimulation
Light effects
Sound effects
Scratching mat
Advantages
  • Cats will love the sound effects
  • Easy to clean
  • Playing and learning combined
Disadvantages
  • Scratching mat is not included
  • No light effects
Amazon The Natural Pet Company cat toy
Rating

6

The Natural Pet Company cat toy
Customer rating
amazon 1,145 ratings
Deal
Available at
amazon
eBay
Manufacturer
Material
Number of parts
1
Age recommendation
Cub, Adult
Simple cleaning
Fillable with snacks
Strap
Floating
Dental care
Mental stimulation
Light effects
Sound effects
Scratching mat
Advantages
  • Easy to clean
Disadvantages
  • Doesn't come with a scratching mat
  • No light effects
Amazon Karlie 46018
Rating

7

Karlie 46018
Customer rating
amazon 528 ratings