Comparison numbers
| 15 | Products researched | |
| 5 | Research hours | |
| 370 | Readers | |
| 72,297 | Customer ratings |
Best Eyeliners
Eyeliner Comparison 2025
Sort & Filter
Best Product
Manhattan 1010N
Amazon
Bestseller
L'Oreal Superliner Perfect Slim
Amazon
Maybelline Lasting Drama
Amazon
ARTDECO eyeliner
Amazon
ARTDECO eyeliner
Amazon
Max Factor Colour X-Pert Waterproof
Amazon
L'Oreal eyeliner
Amazon
Available at
Manufacturer
Quantity
Colour
Consistency
Opacity
Skin types
Effect
Vegan
Packaging
Shipping (Amazon)
Best Product
1
Manhattan 1010N
Customer rating
5,156 reviewsCheck Price
Available at
see vendordays
see vendordays00$
Manufacturer
Manhattan
Quantity
1,3 g
Colour
Sand
Consistency
Creamy
Opacity
Skin types
Effect
Vegan
Packaging
Pen
Shipping (Amazon)
see vendorCheck Price
Bestseller
2
L'Oreal Superliner Perfect Slim
Customer rating
9,739 reviewsCheck Price
Available at
see vendordays00$
see vendordays00$
see vendordays5.175.17$
see vendordays3.993.99$
see vendordays00$
see vendordays4.994.99$
Manufacturer
L'Oreal
Quantity
9,2 ml
Colour
Sand, Light
Consistency
Hard, Runny
Opacity
Strong, Medium
Skin types
Normal skin
Effect
Vegan
Packaging
Pen
Shipping (Amazon)
see vendorCheck Price
3
Maybelline Lasting Drama
Customer rating
4,914 reviewsCheck Price
Available at
see vendordays00$
see vendordays1.951.95$
5 daysdays00$
Manufacturer
Maybelline
Quantity
2,5 ml
Colour
Sand
Consistency
Hard, Runny
Opacity
Strong, Medium
Skin types
All skin types
Effect
Drip tray
Vegan
Packaging
Pen
Shipping (Amazon)
5 daysCheck Price
4
ARTDECO eyeliner
Customer rating
575 reviewsCheck Price
Available at
see vendordays00$
see vendordays
2-3 daysdays00$
Manufacturer
ARTDECO
Quantity
10 ml
Colour
Sand, Light
Consistency
Hard, Runny
Opacity
Skin types
Sensitive skin
Effect
Pimples
Vegan
Packaging
Pen
Shipping (Amazon)
2-3 daysCheck Price
5
ARTDECO eyeliner
Customer rating
917 reviewsCheck Price
Available at
see vendordays
see vendordays2.72.7$
see vendordays4.994.99$
see vendordays00$
see vendordays2.992.99$
Manufacturer
ARTDECO
Quantity
31 ml
Colour
Rosé, Rose, Light, Sand
Consistency
Creamy, Hard
Opacity
Strong
Skin types
Effect
Active care
Vegan
Packaging
Pen
Shipping (Amazon)
see vendorCheck Price
6
Max Factor Colour X-Pert Waterproof
Customer rating
1,357 reviewsCheck Price
Available at
see vendordays00$
see vendordays00$
see vendordays3.993.99$
see vendordays00$
Manufacturer
Max Factor
Quantity
4,2 ml
Colour
Rose, Rosé
Consistency
Hard, Runny
Opacity
Strong
Skin types
All skin types
Effect
Drip tray
Vegan
Packaging
Pen
Shipping (Amazon)
see vendorCheck Price
7
L'Oreal eyeliner
Customer rating
1,009 reviewsCheck Price
Available at
see vendordays
see vendordays00$
Manufacturer
L'Oreal
Quantity
3 ml
Colour
Consistency
Creamy, Hard
Opacity
Skin types
Effect
Vegan
Packaging
Pen
Shipping (Amazon)
see vendorCheck Price
